Will there be any change in the composition of the US Supreme Court in 2023?
  • 381
  • 97
  • $28,864
If a new justice is confirmed to the Supreme Court before 2024, the event will resolve in favor of yes. The outcome depends on the exclusive authority of Scott Alexander, who determined that most likely justices dying or resigning, but court packing would also qualify as changes in composition. The resolution criteria specify that predictions will only count for Metaculus track records and will not be evaluated by Alexander. A change in membership size before 2050 is considered relevant to the broader question of a potential change in the Supreme Court's composition. A decrease in conservative justices on January 20, 2025, is also seen as related, but a more specific and narrowly focused event.

Probability History

0102030405060708090100↑ ProbabilityJan2023AprJulOctJan2024

Source: brier.fyi

Detailed Scores

Criterion Grade Brier/QuadraticLogarithmicSpherical
At Market Midpoint
B
0.0036
-0.0619
0.9980
Time-Weighted Average
B
0.0037
-0.0624
0.9979
30 Days Before Close
S
0.0001
-0.0101
0.9999
7 Days Before Close
S
0.0001
-0.0101
0.9999
Relative Score
B
-0.007
+0.034
+0.005
Criterion Grade Brier/QuadraticLogarithmicSpherical
At Market Midpoint
D
0.0501
-0.2533
0.9609
Time-Weighted Average
C-
0.0173
-0.1409
0.9887
30 Days Before Close
A
0.0013
-0.0367
0.9993
7 Days Before Close
A+
0.0003
-0.0181
0.9998
Relative Score
C-
+0.007
-0.034
-0.005
  • Overall
  • 381
  • 97
  • $28,864
Criterion Grade Brier/QuadraticLogarithmicSpherical
At Market Midpoint
D+
0.0268
-0.1576
0.9794
Time-Weighted Average
C
0.0105
-0.1017
0.9933
30 Days Before Close
A+
0.0007
-0.0234
0.9996
7 Days Before Close
A+
0.0002
-0.0141
0.9999

Similar Questions

  • 610
  • $142,419

Kalshi
B+
-0.009
Manifold
D+
+0.012
Metaculus
C
+0.002
  • 163
  • $128,069

Kalshi
C-
+0.010
Manifold
D
+0.017
Metaculus
B
-0.008
  • 568
  • $4,447

Manifold
A+
-0.047
Metaculus
F
+0.047
  • 132
  • $175

Manifold
C-
+0.008
Metaculus
B
-0.008
  • 524
  • $1,464

Manifold
C
+0.003
Metaculus
B-
-0.003
  • 342
  • $178

Manifold
F
+0.043
Metaculus
A+
-0.043