Prediction Market Platforms

Prediction market platforms are the backbones of this entire endeavour. These entities develop market mechanisms, fund web hosting, run community management, provide dispute resolution, and do a thousand other little things that keep prediction markets useful.
With the wide responsibilities that these platforms carry, they have to make certain decisions about how to focus their efforts. Taking into account their users, goals, and long-term strategies, each platform has eventually selected or settled into their own niches. For example, Kalshi specializes in recurring CFTC-approved contracts, Manifold allows any user to make any market (with play money), and Polymarket operates high-volume contracts on blockchain networks.
You may notice that Metaculus is not like the other platforms. Metaculus is a platform focused on forecasting, not trading, and so their structure is quite different. There are simply user predictions, that can be changed, and aggregations. However, their goal is still to forecast the future and we can still grade them on how well they accomplish that!

Kalshi

  • 259,570
  • $4,059,429,045

Kalshi is the first CFTC-regulated prediction market exchange in the United States, launched in 2021. The platform allows users to trade on event contracts with real money. Kalshi's unique position as a regulated entity means it maintains strict compliance standards while offering a legitimate way to hedge against real-world events. The platform uses a central limit order book model and emphasizes transparency in market operations.

The platform has a large number of short-duration, high frequency markets for predictions on common events. It generates revenue from fees on market orders and is required to limit individual positions to $25,000 per market.

Category Markets Midpoint Brier Relative Score
Culture
22
F
0.2996
A-
-0.013
Economics
13
D
0.0727
B+
-0.008
Politics
88
D-
0.1597
B
-0.006
Science
20
D
0.1046
C-
+0.004
Sports
19
F
0.2825
A-
-0.015
Technology
16
F
0.2997
A-
-0.014
Overall
178
D-
0.1901
B
-0.0075

Manifold

  • 136,565
  • 2,475,006
  • $175,294,861

Manifold is a prediction market platform launched in 2021 that uses play money (called 'mana') to allow users to create and trade on virtually any topic. The platform's unique feature is its permissionless nature - anyone can create markets about anything, from major world events to personal goals.

In order to provide liquidity on the huge number of markets, the platform uses an automated market maker while also allowing user limit orders and bots. Mana can be earned through the site's numerous social features, such as betting streaks, trader bonuses, and monthly leagues. The site is sustained by users purchasing mana or boosts to drive engagement on their markets.

Category Markets Midpoint Brier Relative Score
Culture
30
D-
0.2325
D-
+0.018
Economics
33
D-
0.1251
D
+0.011
Politics
209
D-
0.1762
D+
+0.005
Science
30
D-
0.2010
D+
+0.008
Sports
35
F
0.4346
D
+0.013
Technology
27
F
0.2884
D+
+0.005
Overall
364
D-
0.2114
D+
0.0076

Metaculus

  • 4,679
  • 482,773

Metaculus is a sophisticated forecasting platform established in 2015 that focuses on aggregating predictions about scientific, technological, and social events. Unlike traditional prediction markets, Metaculus emphasizes forecaster calibration and accuracy over monetary gains. The platform uses advanced aggregation algorithms to combine predictions from its community of forecasters, many of whom are experts in their fields.

Metaculus is known for its long-term forecasting tournaments, detailed discussion forums, and comprehensive tracking of forecaster performance. The site provides detailed information to forecasters and a number of tournaments to incentivise deep desearch, advanced AI bots, and new forecasting techniques.

Category Markets Midpoint Brier Relative Score
Culture
8
D-
0.2018
F
+0.051
Economics
16
D-
0.1270
C-
+0.004
Politics
93
D-
0.1453
C-
+0.003
Science
14
D-
0.2446
B
-0.007
Sports
4
F
0.2536
D-
+0.019
Technology
11
D-
0.1880
D+
+0.004
Overall
146
D-
0.1621
D+
0.0055

Polymarket

  • 37,567
  • 8,432,364
  • $19,543,012,509

Polymarket is a blockchain-based prediction market platform launched in 2020 that allows users to trade on real-world events using cryptocurrency. The site is banned from use in several countries including the US and UK, but these bans are fairly simple to circumvent with VPNs. As such, the platform has a large number of users and very high volume on popular markets.

Market resolutions are determined by a decentralized "optimistic oracle" which incentivises tokenholders to vote on the correct outcome with allowances for disputes or emergency overrides (though some users still intentionally use their voting power to profit). The site also provides rewards for liquidity providers and some negative risk events.

Category Markets Midpoint Brier Relative Score
Culture
26
D-
0.1734
B
-0.008
Economics
16
D-
0.1245
A-
-0.011
Politics
157
D-
0.1627
C+
-0.001
Science
16
D
0.0622
A
-0.025
Sports
26
F
0.2633
A-
-0.011
Technology
13
D-
0.1534
C+
-0.001
Overall
254
D-
0.1649
B
-0.0047